The World Trade Organization ended its 14th Ministerial Conference in Yaoundé, Cameroon, early on 30 March 2026 without adopting its main texts. The moratorium on customs duties on electronic transmissions was not renewed and expired at the end of March, and a declaration on reforming the organisation went back to Geneva unfinished. Since then members have worked increasingly in groups: 62 settle appeals through an interim arrangement, 25 co-sponsors (with the EU counted as one) have promised among themselves to keep digital trade duty-free, and China's trade negotiator has called for initiatives to go ahead without every member.1 2 3 4
What Yaoundé did and did not decide
According to the WTO, ministers agreed to keep negotiating fisheries subsidies and adopted two decisions prepared in Geneva, on small economies and on special treatment under the food-safety and technical-standards agreements. The WTO's account says ministers "ran out of time" to adopt the e-commerce work programme and to renew the moratorium on duties on electronic transmissions and a moratorium on certain intellectual-property complaints, and that both moratoria expire at the end of March 2026. The conference chair, Cameroon's trade minister Luc Magloire Mbarga Atangana, used the same words.1
Director-General Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala described the setting, as reported by People's Daily, China's state newspaper.5
全球贸易体系正经历80年来最严重的动荡。
The global trading system is going through its worst turbulence in 80 years.5
The European Union told the General Council on 6 and 7 May 2026 that "we must take collective responsibility for this setback" and that restoring the moratorium "remains an urgent priority". It also asked for the Investment Facilitation for Development Agreement, backed by about 130 members, to be written into WTO rules "as a matter of priority".2
Who blocked what
The camps describe the e-commerce failure differently. Third World Network, a non-governmental news service based in Penang, Malaysia, reports that the United States first sought a permanent moratorium and then a four-year extension, and that Brazil held out for the customary two years after Türkiye dropped its objection.3
Twenty-five co-sponsors, with the EU counted as one and including the United States, Japan and Britain, then circulated a text, dated 1 September 2026, saying they will "continue to not impose customs duties on electronic transmissions among ourselves" from 8 May 2026. Separately, India and Pakistan objected in July to the Director-General acting as depositary for a plurilateral Agreement on Electronic Commerce, which the United States has not joined. Unnamed envoys quoted by the service described the WTO's drift as "institutional lawlessness".3
China's case for groups of the willing
China's government, which describes the WTO as the core of the trading system, now argues for more flexible decision-making. At a meeting of trade ministers in Paris on 3 June 2026, Vice Minister Li Chenggang said, according to the Commerce Ministry:4
成员应探索更灵活、更包容的决策方式,允许符合大多数成员利益的倡议通过诸边方式在世贸组织框架内先行一步。
Members should explore more flexible and inclusive ways of deciding, and allow initiatives that serve the interests of most members to go ahead first within the WTO framework through plurilateral means.4
On this point Beijing and Brussels are on the same side. The EU wants the investment facilitation agreement added to WTO rules, and People's Daily reports that China pushed its negotiations forward at Yaoundé. India's objection to the Director-General's role in the e-commerce agreement shows that some members reject rule-making by subgroups.2 3 4 5
An appeal system for some members
The WTO's Appellate Body has been unable to hear appeals since December 2019, when it lost its quorum. On 25 September 2026 Colombia, for 130 members, proposed for the 100th time to begin filling its seats, and the United States again declined.6
Les États-Unis ont dit qu'ils ne soutenaient pas la décision proposée.
The United States said that it did not support the proposed decision.6
The substitute is the multi-party interim appeal arbitration arrangement, under which participants agree not to appeal "into the void". The European Commission says it was set up in 2020 and sends appeals to arbitrators chosen at random from a pool of ten. The WTO said in March that it had 61 participants and had resolved two appeals. The European Commission said on 9 September 2026 that Cambodia's entry took it to 62 members covering 60.4% of world trade.7 8
The United States is outside it. A ruling against Washington can still be appealed to the non-functioning Appellate Body, leaving it without effect.6 7
Security as a defence
The other strain on WTO law is the security exception in Article XXI of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, which lets a member take measures it "considers necessary" to protect essential security interests. When it accepted consultations with Canada over the 2025 tariffs, the United States said that "issues of national security" are "not susceptible to review or capable of resolution by WTO dispute settlement".9
Panels have disagreed. In the dispute over the US rule requiring Hong Kong goods to be marked "China", the panel ruled in December 2022 that it could review whether the exception's conditions were met, and found no "emergency in international relations". The United States appealed in January 2023, and the case has stood still since.10
The refusals have continued past the 100th. At the Dispute Settlement Body meeting of 27 October 2026 the proposal was tabled again, and the United States said it "does not support the proposed decision", arguing that reviving the Appellate Body as proposed is "a guarantee that a well-functioning dispute settlement system will not happen". The draft reform declaration from Yaoundé was sent back to Geneva, and none of the sources read for this article reports its adoption.1 11