The US Court of International Trade will hear on 20 January 2027 the first challenge to the 50% tariffs on Canadian goods, according to the trade publication Inside U.S. Trade. The suit was filed on 20 October 2026 by Gellert Global Group, a food importer from New Jersey. It asks the court to rule that Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, a provision no president had used before this year, does not allow the tariffs, and to order refunds for the company and for a proposed class of importers.1 2 3
What the statute says
Section 338 is part of the Smoot-Hawley tariff law of 1930. It lets the president proclaim new or additional duties on the goods of a country that he finds places an unreasonable burden on American products that it does not place on others, or that discriminates in fact against American commerce. The duty is meant to offset the burden and may not exceed 50% of the value of the goods. The text says such duties take effect 30 days after the proclamation. If the discrimination continues, the president may go further and bar the country's goods from entry.4
The statute tells the US International Trade Commission to watch for discrimination and report it to the president. It requires no investigation and no public hearing before a tariff is imposed, which is the main difference from Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, the law normally used against foreign trade practices.4 5
A Canadian law firm, Borden Ladner Gervais, described the provision to French-speaking clients in July:
Il autorise le président américain à imposer des droits de douane maximaux de 50 % sur les importations d'un pays s'il considère comme un fait établi que ce pays exerce une discrimination à l'égard du commerce américain.
It authorises the American president to impose customs duties of up to 50% on imports from a country if he finds as a fact that the country discriminates against American commerce.6
The firm adds that the law does not define discrimination.6
What Washington did with it
Three proclamations of 20 July 2026 found that Canada discriminates against American commerce in three ways: provincial liquor boards removed American drinks from their shelves, Canada allocates its dairy import quotas in a way Washington objects to, and Canada has charged 25% on American vehicles since 9 April 2025. The annexes go well beyond those sectors, to wine, cosmetics, cement, paper and wood products, clothing, machinery, furniture and hockey sticks.6 2
The goods are worth about $20 billion a year, a little over 5% of what the United States buys from Canada. Energy, potash, critical minerals, fish and goods already paying sector tariffs under Section 232 are left out. Goods that qualify under the North American trade agreement are not exempt. The proclamations named 19 August as the start, according to Borden Ladner Gervais; the consultancy Sandler, Travis & Rosenberg says the duty has applied to goods entered since 22 August, with no end date.6 2
The lists have changed twice. Proclamations of 8 September added products, among them the cheeses Gellert imports, with effect from 15 September. A proclamation of 23 October removed 22 products and added 100, with effect from 30 October.3 7
What the importer argues
The suit says Section 338 is a narrow answer to discrimination and not a general power to tax imports. Its first argument is that Congress later wrote Section 301 to deal with unfair foreign practices, with an investigation and public comment, and that the administration cannot avoid those steps by reaching for an older law. Its second is that the Canadian measures named are not discrimination in the statute's sense: two were Canada's replies to American tariffs, and the dairy dispute is governed by the North American agreement. Its third is that the 50% rate was never tied to a measured burden and falls on goods that have nothing to do with the alleged discrimination.2 5
The last argument is about timing. The cheeses were listed on 8 September and taxed seven days later, not after the 30 days the statute names. Gellert says it imported about $71 million of Canadian cheese in 2025 and that the duty will cost it about $40 million a year. It adds that the brie it buys in Canada is made with milk from farms in New York State.3
The company is represented by the Liberty Justice Center, the group that brought the case that ended the emergency-powers tariffs. In a statement reported by Agence France-Presse and carried in Quebec, the centre called the tariffs an8
«excès de pouvoir provoquant des dommages immédiats aux entreprises américaines, leurs fournisseurs et clients»
"abuse of power causing immediate harm to American businesses, their suppliers and customers"8
The government has not yet answered in court. Its brief is due on 11 December and the importer's reply on 11 January, before a panel of three judges. The court has not certified the proposed class.9 5
Canada's position
Canada is not a party to the case. Prime Minister Mark Carney called the proclamations a direct violation of the North American agreement while saying he remained open to talks. On 25 August Ottawa announced counter-tariffs on C$27.6 billion of American goods, at 15%, 25% or 50%, in force since 8 September, with C$7.5 billion of support for affected workers and firms.6 10
The hearing on 20 January falls ten days after the reply brief. The court has not said when it will rule, and the tariffs stay in force until it does.1 9