Trade WarFigures as of 16 November 2026

The 10% surcharge ended in July, but only three plaintiffs have a refund order

The US trade court ruled the Section 122 surcharge unlawful in May and limited refunds to two importers and one state. That ruling is on hold at the appeals court, and other importers must protect their own claims.

The law 16 November 2026

The 10% surcharge that the United States charged on nearly all imports from 24 February to 24 July 2026 has been ruled unlawful once, by the Court of International Trade on 7 May 2026. The ruling ordered refunds for three plaintiffs only, and the appeals court has put it on hold. Briefing in the appeal was due to end on 12 November. No court has ordered refunds for the other importers that paid, and Customs has no refund process for this tariff.1 2 3

What the surcharge was

Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974 lets the president impose a surcharge of up to 15% for up to 150 days to deal with large and serious balance-of-payments deficits. President Trump invoked it in Proclamation 11012 of 20 February 2026, the day the Supreme Court struck down the tariffs based on emergency powers. The proclamation set 10% and cited the trade deficit and the current-account deficit. The surcharge expired on 24 July, when the 150 days ran out, and tariffs under Section 301 replaced it.1 3

What the trade court decided

Two small importers, a spice company and a toy company, and a group of 24 states led by Oregon sued in March. The court heard them on 10 April and ruled on 7 May, by two judges to one.1 4

The majority held that a trade deficit is not the balance-of-payments deficit Congress had in mind in 1974. It read the term as it was understood when the law was written, as a deficit measured by liquidity, official settlements or the basic balance, and found that the proclamation had shown none of those. The proclamation was therefore outside the president's authority.1

Japan's trade promotion agency, JETRO, reported the limits of the relief to Japanese firms in these words:

IEEPA関税に関する判決とは異なり、今回は訴えが認められた企業・州に対してのみ、関税の還付などが認められた。

Unlike the ruling on the IEEPA tariffs, this time refunds and other relief were granted only to the companies and the state whose claims were upheld.2

Those were Burlap and Barrel, Basic Fun and the state of Washington, which pays duties through its public university. The other 23 states were dismissed because they did not import anything themselves. The court refused an order covering all importers, writing that costs to one plaintiff are not a proper basis for a universal injunction.1 2 5

Where the appeal stands

The government appealed the next day. The Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit paused the ruling on 12 May and on 11 June granted a stay for the length of the appeal, so even the three winners have not been paid. In that order, which sets no precedent, the appeals court said the legislative history "strongly call[s] into question" the trade court's reading, without adopting a reading of its own. It reasoned that the plaintiffs lose little by waiting, since refunds with interest remain available if they win. The states have filed a cross-appeal against their dismissal.1 2 4

The government has filed its opening brief and the challengers have responded. The government's reply was due on 12 November, after a 30-day extension that its lawyers sought because of about two dozen other cases with deadlines in the same month. Inside U.S. Trade reports that the Justice Department argues a balance-of-payments deficit is a "fundamental" problem of the kind the statute addresses. No date for oral argument has been published in the sources read for this article.3 6

What other importers can do

The refund system that Customs built this year, called CAPE, handles only the emergency-powers tariffs. The law firm Troutman Pepper Locke wrote in October that importers outside the case are not covered by the refund order and that it knew of no class action proposed for Section 122 duties.1 5

That leaves two routes, both of which the importer must start itself:

Lawyers also advise firms to check their contracts, because a refund goes to the importer of record even where a customer bore the cost.5

None of the sources read for this article gives an official total for what was collected under the surcharge.1 7

What is still open

The appeals court will decide two things: whether the trade court read "balance-of-payments deficits" correctly, and, if so, who is entitled to money back. A ruling for the government ends the matter unless the Supreme Court takes it. A ruling for the challengers would still leave the question of importers who neither sued nor protested. The first protest windows, on GingerControl's estimate, begin to close in July 2027.1 7

Sources

  1. Troutman Pepper Locke. Getting Duties Back: Where Recovery Stands Under IEEPA, Section 122, and Section 301 Forced Labor Tariffs. 12 October 2026Independent camp · law firm analysis
  2. JETRO (Japan External Trade Organization). 米国際貿易裁判所、122条関税に違法判決、ただし関税を巡る不確実性は続く [US Court of International Trade rules Section 122 tariffs unlawful, but uncertainty over tariffs continues]. 11 May 2026Japan's camp · government trade agency · in Japanese
  3. TaxProf Blog (Jon Endean, Brooklyn Law School). Update on Tariff Challenges. 4 November 2026Independent camp · legal academic blog
  4. Oregon Department of Justice. Tariffs (Oregon v. Trump, Court of International Trade, 1:26-cv-01472). Updated June 2026Plaintiffs' camp · state government party to the case
  5. Snell & Wilmer. More Tariff Refunds? Not So Fast: Court of International Trade Strikes Down Section 122 Tariffs, But Relief Is Limited to Plaintiffs. May 2026Independent camp · law firm analysis
  6. Inside U.S. Trade. Court of International Trade (topic page; headline "DOJ: Balance-of-payments deficit a 'fundamental' problem"). 16 November 2026Independent camp · trade press
  7. GingerControl. Section 122 Refund Rights: 4 Actions to Take Now. 12 October 2026Industry camp · trade compliance vendor

All articles